Discussing ‘The Perfect Heart’ by Shara McCallum

The Perfect Heart
by Shara McCallum

I am alone in the garden, separated
from my class. This is what comes
of trying to make the perfect heart.

Scissors: silvery cold and slipping
through my four-year-old fingers.
I did not know and took the harder route,

tried to carve a mirrored mountain top
from each center of the page
after page of red construction paper.

Now, I am counting the frangipani
in bloom. Teacher’s words still shriller
than a mockingbird’s. My cheeks

wet and hot from more than heat.
If I had been taught, if
once I had been shown the way,

I would have obeyed – not been
a spoiled, rude, wasteful little girl.
Folding the paper in two,
I would have cut away the crescent moon.


Thoughts and Comments

Something I noticed right away when reading this poem was the subtle inclusion of rhymes. For example, “words” and “mockingbird’s” in the fourth stanza, “cheeks” and “heat” in the fourth and fifth stanzas, “way” and “obeyed” in the fifth and sixth stanzas, and “two” and “moon” in the last stanza. Because these rhymes do not necessarily occur at the end of the lines, the poem has rhythm without sounding cheesy, which could have been the case since this poem is about a young child. Another example of effective word choice is “still shriller” in the fourth stanza; not only do the bases of these words rhyme, they form an alliteration.

In the third stanza, I really like “from each center of the page / after page of red construction paper.” The line break after the first “page” and the wording draws the reader’s attention to this part – “center of the page” makes sense, and so does “page after page,” but “center of the page after page” is a bit odd with that “the” included.

While the last line of this stanza is the only time the word “red” is directly used, the color itself appears throughout the poem. First of all, the word “heart” itself alludes to red: anatomically correct hearts are made of red tissues and pump red blood, and the well-known heart shape is typically colored in red. After the actual use of the word, the image of “frangipani” (a type of flower) comes up, which – although not always – can be red. And then, of course, we have the narrators “cheeks” that are “hot from more than heat.” Emotion and temperature both contribute to rosy cheeks.

In the very last stanza, the use of italics for “spoiled, rude, wasteful little girl” conveys the emotion much more effectively than quotations would, I think. This stanza also has four lines while the rest have three, but there isn’t necessarily a reason for this. Overall, the organization into (usually) three-lined stanzas and the capitalization of letters at the beginning of each new sentence allow the reader to easily follow along.

While the title isn’t necessary to provide information to the poem, the use a phrase from the poem itself works out nicely. Though the poem is about a young girl who’s frustrated, crying, and isolated, it is still playful overall.

– Rachel.

Here is a short author bio from Poets.org.
Click to view an interview with Shara McCallum on the process of writing poetry.


2 responses to “Discussing ‘The Perfect Heart’ by Shara McCallum

  1. Lots to like about your presentation and post, Rachel. You provided a nice close examination of the poem’s diction and the way certain thematics or emotions are extended throughout the stanzas. Indeed there are numerous examples of craftily written lines that produce lyrical sounds. I agree that the writing is playful (maybe even beautifully so), but that’s not quite the same as saying the “tone” is playful. For me, it’s quite sad. Our narrator is alone/separated and crying. And I’m picturing a pile of mis-cut (broken?) paper hearts on the floor somewhere. Perhaps this is what comes of trying too hard to achieve “perfection” in matters of the heart. Anyway, glad that you provided the links. That’s the kind of “extra” move that reveals enthusiasm and effort; don’t worry, I’m paying attention. Thanks for working hard.

    Quick blogging tip: You seem to have a handle on the “tricks of the trade” (perhaps you’ve done this before?), but when you include links to other sites, you might want to check the box that causes the links to open in a new browser window. That way readers aren’t forced to leave your site.

    • Okay, you’re right about the writing being playful rather than the tone; I agree. And yes, I’ve worked with html before – it’s been awhile though. The links on my ‘Favorite books.’ page open in a new tab, but I guess I forgot to do it on this. I’ll fix that now. Thanks!

Feedback, comments, or concerns?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s